Life After the Fire logo options

As many of you know, I am working on getting a website up to provide valuable information for those who've lost their homes in a fire.  The web designer has a tentative completion date of the first of May.  I also had a design contest on MycroBurst.com to get a logo designed.

I have five days to pick a finalist, and I'm struggling with my decision, so I'd love if you had any input!  One of the designs I loved I actually decided against after a few people gave me their impression.  It wasn't the look I was going for!  I have a poll at the bottom, and I'd love more specific feedback about why you liked or didn't like a specific design if you're willing to share!

#1

 

#2

 

#3

 

#4

 

#5

 

Which design do you like best?